Wednesday, January 19, 2011

Is Idol smarter than a 5th grader?

That's right, friends, Idol is starting its 10th season. Gone is the triumvirate of Randy-Paula-Simon to be replaced by Randy-Jennifer-Steven. I can't say I'm unhappy with the new panel, but I'll have to wait and see if it works out.

Personally, I wish they'd have kept Ellen and replaced Randy, who was always the most superflous of the "judges". The old panel had chemistry (before they effed it up by introducing Kara) and I think that's part of the reason why Ellen left. Of course, now that her main antagonist (Simon) is also gone, she could have done a good job to flourish on her own.

Nigel has promised lots of changes, of which I'm sure I'll be talking about as the season drags on, but the biggest is the departure of Simon Cowell. I'm actually happy he left. His frankness was refreshing when the show debuted, but now it's kind of cliche. My other problem with Cowell is that for the last four or so years, he's been phoning it in, and for the last two (if not three), he's been obviously bored with the whole thing. As if it were a burden on him to make tens of millions of dollars to show up for Idol.

Seacrest is also back, and I hope Nigel reins him in and keeps him from making the show about him and not the singers. They've also dispensed with the forced gender equity going into the top 12 (yay!) and lowered the age limit to 15 (boo!).

In other news, I'm still playing my hunter, but I've recently made my main LOTRO character an elf minstrel, who is also level 65 and I've started playing a captain who is now level 55. I'm playing way too much LOTRO, but at least I'm staying out of trouble (mostly). Look me up on Elendilmir; I'm an officer in our kinship, The Druadan. I'm usually logged on as Vraeden, Vuvuzeyla or Voontak (no, the V's are not for "Vistors").

As the show opens, the screen says the show is "ours". That's refreshing. For the past several seasons, it seems Idol has been more about Seacrest and keeping Simon entertained than the singing. I also hope they go back to being about affirming singers and choosing a good singer, not highlighting trainwrecks or being mean to people (remember "the other door" stunt and what they did to Judd?).

I'm very happy to see the always-hawt J-Lo. Not so much for the really unattractive Steven Tyler (his daughter Liv, on the other hand . . .). I hope they work out, and on the face of it, the two new judges have cache and real name recognition, unlike Kara and to a lesser extent Paula. I just wish they would have replaced Randy as well. Maybe he'll stop trying to be ghetto and become the reasonable voice he used to be.

Under the old panel, there was a producer, a performer and an executive. Each had a role and perspective. Now we've got a producer, a performer and a maybe washed-up/burned-out legend. There was also an MC who kept things moving, but then he dumped the co-host and tried to make the show about him. I think they should have dumped Randy, kept Ellen and replaced Seacrest with Harry Connick, Jr. But that's just my wish list.

I'm not going to talk too much about the initial audition shows, since I think they're mostly filler and they spend too much time highlighting the William Hungs of the world or handing people votes with their sob stories (Anthony Fedorov), their aw-shucks stories (Carrie Underwood) or outright pimping the handful of singers the producers want to win (Gokey, Archuleta). We'll find out if Idol has turned a corner if they actually have a level playing field going in to the Hollywood rounds.

Since my last Idol post, we've switched from Comcast (those bastards!) to DirecTV, whom I'm pretty happy with. I had to keep my Comcast cable internet because we life too far from the nearest DSL switch, but I like DirecTV so much better than Comcast. We get more HD channels, we actually get the channels we pay for and I haven't been jerked around every five months when Comcast feels like jacking up the monthly premium.

I just got a glimpse of FRC, and a little part of me just died when the eye-boink hit me like Call of Oromë striking an orc.

The first two singers they show are put through, and I wonder if we're going to spend the season wondering what's in Steven's cup. We also get our first glimpse of a 15 year old auditioner. I've said before that 16 is too young, and I definitely feel that a 15 year old will get chewed up and spit out by the show (Jaclyn Crum, anyone?).

As the show goes on, I'm going to do some word association:

Big boobs (good)

Oversinging (bad)

Crying (very bad)

"Miracle" babies (blech)

Falsetto (cringe)

J-Lo (yum)

Boy Scouts (why don't they sell cookies?)

Commericals (yawn)

Begging the judges (no pride)

Victoria Huggins (Carrie Underwood if she had a North Carolina twang, oversang everything, and was annoying as hell)

16 year-olds who dress like they're 22 (jail)

Brooklynn Decker (damn you, Andy Roddick!)

Mrs. High Lord was ticked off at me the other day. You see, we came home from work one day and a bunch of stuff I bought on eBay showed up. Namely, a Microsoft Sidewinder X6 keyboard, Logitech G13 gamepad, Razer Naga mouse and Razer Carcharias headset. My MMO setup is bad-ass. It's too bad I haven't quite gotten the whole PvP thing down yet (but I'm working on it! I'm really looking forward to the new Star Wars MMO that's supposed to drop in April.

I figure while I'm in the doghouse I may as well make the most of my time there. I'm thinking of trading in my car for a new one. I've got an RX-8, and while there's nothing wrong with it, I'm approaching my midlife crisis, so I'm thinking about getting the new Toyota/Scion FT-86, Nissan 370Z or perhaps a BMW 1-series coupe. You'll know I'm in trouble if I ask for a place to crash for a while.

To offset that, I'm sending her to Florida next month to visit her BFF in Orlando and go to Harry Potter land at Universal Studios. That should score me bunches of points. Then later this year, I think we're going to Hawaii. That should get me a new sports car, right? Or at least an iPhone 5 when they drop in June . . .

Last fall, I tried to pre-emptively tried to score some points by buying Mrs. High Lord an iPad. She's been looking for an eReader device, and we had tried out the MicroVelocity Cruz Reader, but it had some issues booting up and some problems with the Android OS, so we traded it in. While she was out of town, I bought it for her after Borders gave me my money back on the Cruz (which will probably be good in its second generation after they work all the bugs out). So far, it's a great device, but before you get it, know that an iPad is not a laptop (even though its priced like one) and you shouldn't expect it to do laptop things. But if you want a device that will surf the internet, let you check your mail and play Angry Birds, the iPad is a marvelous device (aside from the price).

Overall first impressions of tonight: Lots off good singers got shown. A few bad ones. The new judges's table looks like a lot of fun. Seacrest is not being shown as prominently. I hate that the show is on Wednesday/Thursday now because that's really going to mess with my other favourite show: The Big Bang Theory (DVR: Good!).

Tomorrow, we're going to N'Awlins, so I'll see you then.

High Lord. Diminisher of Giants. Out.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

i really liked steven tyler and jennifer lopez - they are very likeable, quite kind and still honest.I hated last season, but i think the new judges will be a great improvement...thanks for blogging!
Connie

Laura said...

Hey Dave - looking forward to a good idol season (it can't get much worse from last season, so it has to be an improvement, right?)

Laura

BeckEye said...

I don't like the schedule change. But at least the results show is supposed to be 30 minutes this year (so they've promised) so it shouldn't interfere with too many of my Thursday night shows.

First show was fairly boring. I guess that's about normal.