The show that is everything American Idol should have been is back. It's Rock Star: Supernova on CBS, featuring a contrived band made up of Tommy Lee, James Newstead and Gilby Clarke.
Back for more are Dave Navarro and Brooke Burke. Plus, the band's producer Butch Walker is sitting in with the band and giving feedback. Of all the judges, he's the one I would pay the most attention to; after all, he's going to be shaping the sound more than anyone else.
The show opens showing last year's winner Jackass touring with our band, INXS. Unfortunately, CBS has put it up against So You Think You Can Dance, but at least it's not on late at night, which was the show's problem last year.
Then it's on to the first performance from
Storm which is allegedly her real name. She's singing "Pinball Wizard" by The Who. I'm not wild about it and she's got that look in her eyes; the one that suggests she's either really on her game or that she's psycho.
Verdict: ↔
Next up is
Ryan who shares the same name as a former American Idol contestant, but has different plumbing. He sings "Name" by Goo Goo Dolls and I think he's weak. He finishes strong, but I he's definitely bottom 3 material.
Verdict: ↓
In the three-hole is
Toby, who was so remarkable that I forgot what he sang. I'll look it up tomorrow. I do remember that he wasn't bad, but he wasn't good, either. EDIT: It was "Knockin' On Heaven's Door" and he did more of the Guns N' Roses version than the Bob Dylan arrangement.
Verdict: ↔
Batting clean-up is
Patricia who rocks the house with Jefferson Airplane's "Somebody to Love". She was good, definitely better than Storm. The thing she has going for her is that she sounds very polished, something Ryan and Toby did not.
Verdict: ↑
Going fifth is the pride of Iceland,
Magni singing "Satisfaction". He was okay. Not great; his voice is okay but he stage act isn't great.
Verdict: ↔
In sixth place is
Zayra who sings an Evanesence song (I forget the title) and radiates sex appeal. The song is okay, but she's going to be one who cruises by on her good looks rather than her actual talent (I'm projecting her to be this year's Ace).
Verdict: ↔
Seventh up is
Jenny singing "You Remind Me" by Nickelback. She doesn't have a big voice, but she's good. I don't know that she's right for a band with Tommy Lee in it, but if she could just get a contract, she could do well.
Verdict: ↑
Turning the half-way point is
Josh, who puts out a rendition of "She Talks to Angels" that is a little mush-mouthed, but okay. He looks a little like the Sherminator, but other than that, I like him. How old is he though? 15? If Supernova plays a club, do you think he'll get carded on the way in?
Verdict: ↔
Now it's time for reformed real estate corporate suit is
Matt singing "Yellow". I've never liked this song, so let's hope he can change my mind about it. Ptichy makes its first appearance of the night. I think he's bottom 3 material, too.
Verdict: ↓
In the 10 spot is Dilana and she's singing a song I
really can't stand, "Lithium". She scares me. Especially with the Sith Lord hood action she's got happening. Her voice is actually pretty good, but I don't think I can get past the thought that she would kill a chicken if it were thrown on stage. My wife says she has a slug sticking out of her chin.
Verdict: ↔
Kicking off the final third of the show is
Dana. She's the token small-town girl, and her intro piece makes her out to be the Rock Star version of Carrie Underwood. Unfortunately for Dana, she's taken on "I'm the Only One" and I think it's the wrong song for her. She spent too much time in the lower register, but I don't think the guys were paying attention to her voice. In my opinion, she's another bottom 3 candidate.
Verdict: ↓
Next up is
Phil singing "Cult of Personality". Phil is weak. His voice isn't as big as the song needs, and he looks kind of goofy on stage. My wife was watching So You Think You Can Dance so I didn't get to hear all of his performance or the band's comments, but it sounded like they were ripping him for song choice.
Verdict: ↔
The lucky 13th performance is Jill with "Piece of My Heart". She's good on stage, but like Phil, her voice is weak.
Verdict: ↓
Chris sings "Roxanne". The guys from the band have a look on their faces that says, "What the hell is that guy singing?" There's a lot of shouting, but not a lot of singing. He's another bottom 3 candidate.
Verdict: ↓
Wrapping up the singing is scary-looking
Lukas singing "Rebel Yell". It's a good thing he's Canadian, or I'd be worried about him being an axe-murderer. He's also a shouter, but the band seemed to like him. Not so much for me.
Verdict: ↓
"The World" is now voting to send three people to the bottom 3 and then the band will eliminate one person tomorrow night. Unlike last year, when they had the "after the show" program on VH-1, this year, all the extra stuff is only available online. I'll check it out tomorrow while I'm at "work".
It's a shame that one person has to go after only a week, but there are clearly some performers who are weaker than others. Last year, our band INXS eliminated one person on the first show (before there was any voting) and if that had happened this year, based on tonight's performances, it would have been Chris.
My picks for the bottom 3: Chris, Dana, Matt
I'd like to have heard two different songs from each person before getting to the voting, but at least there aren't any audition shows for CBS to pimp some contestants at the expense of others.
We'll see how it goes tomorrow night.